Caramoan versus previous season

First, I'd like to apologize for the name of this blog post. I can't think of a better name. I've decided that of all the contestants on Caramoan who had played a season before this season is worth mentioning in this post. I will name the contestant in question and how they did in their first season versus how they did in Caramoan. I will see if I can do a comparison of the ten favorites. I will go in the order they were eliminated from in Caramoan and I will mention as many facts as I can before deciding which one was the better game they played. I hope that you enjoy it.

contestant	summary of their time on their first season	summary of their time on Caramoan	which season they did better in
Francesca	She started the game on the 22nd season. She found herself on the outs with a crazy would be alliance member who helped screw her out of the game. She wanted to get rid of the returning player and failed. She played too hard too soon. She was the first voted out and sent to Redemption Island. She was the first to lose a duel on Redemption Island and thus the first eliminated.	She became a favorite despite being a first boot in her original season. She had to endure being on the same tribe as the person who screwed her from the game the first time. She was certain that she wasn't going to be the first boot again. She played too hard too soon. She ultimately was the first one voted out again.	It's hard to say which one she did better in. I'd pretty much have to say that the second time around wasn't that good and her first time was good for a while. So I'd have to say that she did better on Redemption Island.
Brandon	He started the game in the 23rd season. He is related to a previous villain and three time Survivor contestant. He did not want his family name to define his time in the game. He made a lot of dumb decisions and wasn't very smart. He made it to the merge part of the game. He went down as one of, if not the stupidest, Survivor contestants ever. He gave up his immunity necklace and was voted out as a result. He was blindsided. He lost the last Redemption Island duel.	He came off as cocky and arrogant. He made a lot of bad decisions and was always on the outs in his tribe. He sabotaged their camp, threw out their food, and pretty knew that he wasn't going to win. His tribe gave up immunity just so they could vote him out. He did not get a torch snuffed, although he was eliminated from the game. He did not make the merge or jury.	It's hard to say that he played a good game on either season. I'd pretty much have to believe that since he did somewhat good on South Pacific, that's the season I'd give him the better score in.
Corrine	She started the game in the 17th season. She survived numerous tribe shuffles and made the eventual merge. She was disliked by most of the people who watched and is considered a villain to many people. She was on the jury and said many hateful things to Sugar.	She was a returning player, despite being from before the twentieth season. She did better than most returning players from her season, although still not as good as she'd hoped. She made the merge but not the jury. She was blindsided.	Although it's hard to think she did better in one season, I'd think she was best in Gabon.
Phillip	He first appeared on the 22st season. He was a crazy person and one of the most entertaining Survivor players of all time. He was a goat that could be brought to the end to guarantee a win against him. He made it the farthest the first time than any other favorite. He seemed to be a blind follower. He was the runner-up with only one vote to win.	He helped create a core and dominant alliance throughout the game. Most of his rivals got voted out. He made a dumb move at an immunity challenge and got blindsided due to two hidden immunity idols.	I have no idea which season he did better in. I'd have to say it was probably a tie between them both.
Malcolm	He first appeared in the 25th season. He was put on a tribe that was pretty bad before being put on a tribe that was really good. He was a strong player and jury threat. He was the last voted out.	He returned to the game, despite the fact that his season hadn't aired yet. He was the first back to back player to do considerably worse the second time. He was a master of the hidden immunity idol and saved himself once with one while convincing someone else to play one for him earlier. He was on the jury again.	This one I'd have to say is a tie again.
Andrea	She first appeared in the 22nd season. She was in a showmance with another contestant. She got voted out twice. She won Redemption Island duels.	She found a hidden immunity idol, didn't play it, and got voted out as a result.	I'd have to go with Redemption Island as the better season.
Brenda	She first appeared in the 21st season. She was put on the younger tribe. She made it to the merge, only to have herself taken out for reasons that went unaired.	She was the only player from this season to return. She got an injury that went unexplained throughout most of the game and didn't affect it badly. She was blindsided.	Pretty sure she did better in Caramoan.
Erik	He first appeared in the 16th season. He was a superfan that did pretty well in the game. He had many immunity wins before he gave up the necklace and got voted out.	He returned to the game, despite not being a contestant before heroes versus villains. He gave up tribal immunity to the other tribe and the hidden immunity idol to another contestant. He was doing pretty well until he was medically evacuated from the game.	I'd say it's a tie.
Dawn	She first appeared in the 23rd season. She got far in the game, before ultimately being voted out thanks to Pagonging of her tribe.	She got in the right alliances this time around. She had a great alliance with the person who thought she most deserved to be in the finals, which she was in. She did get upset a lot about various things.	Although one can't be too sure, I'd have to say Caramoan.
John Cochran	He first appeared on the 23rd season. He was a superfan of the show and insisted on being called by his last name. His tribe hated him and that caused him to flip. That didn't help him so he got voted out and put on the jury.	He never had a vote cast against him. He won the game unanimously. He changed a lot, for the better.	Obviously, Caramoan.

 

I hope that you enjoyed this post. I also hoped that you understood it.