The Perfect Game Comparison

In Survivor, one can play a so called perfect game if they meet these requirements: 1- they have made it to the final tribal council as a finalist, 2- not a single vote has been cast against them over the entire game, and 3- they win the game unanimously. To date, only two people, JT and Cochran, have accomplished this feat. I will compare their perfect games to see which one, if any, played a better game. I will keep this simply to facts and leave opinions out of it. It could end up as a tie. We'll see. Hopefully I can put a table into this.

What JT did	What John Cochran did	Who wins the point
faced a jury of seven	faced a jury of eight	Cochran
did perfect game first, before anyone else	was the second person to play a perfect game	JT
did a perfect game the first time he played the game	did a perfect game the second time he played the game	JT
was in a final two	was in a final three	Cochran
was on a season with 16 contestants	was on a season with 20 contestants	Cochran
won the Sprint player of the season award	did not win the Sprint player of the season award	JT
did not have an advantage at the final immunity challenge	had an advantage at the final immunity challenge	JT
was on the minority tribe for the first part of the game	was on the majority tribe for the first part of the game	JT
his tribe was best post merge	his tribe was mostly bad post merge (the second incarnation, at least)	Cochran
voted for everyone on the jury minus two	voted for everyone on the jury minus one	Cochran
had four members of his tribe make the merge	had eight members of his original tribe and five members of his swapped tribe make the merge	JT
did not have to outlast a returning player	had to outlast an entire tribe of returning players, excluding himself of course	Cochran
didn't do as well the other time he played	did pretty good the other time he played, playing more days	Cochran
barely had any votes the other time he played	had a lot of votes the other time he played	JT

 

I can't think of what else to include. Maybe I was making responses out of nothing. But I guess that it's a tie. JT and Cochran played the same quality of perfect game, even though they had different ways of doing it. Who knows? Maybe JT and Cochran can be a one returnee per tribe season and battle it out over the perfect game. But who knows what will happen. I hope that you like this, even though it seems pretty strange.