Survivor All Last Voted Out

Poor Survivor contestants that are voted out last. They made it merely one day short of being in the finals. They might have won the game if they could somehow avoid their fate. You'd have to imagine that they could be bitter about what happened, although probably not as bitter as the finalists with no jury votes. I'd have to say that they would be great contestants to choose from for a season just about them. All of the last voted out playing the game again would be nice. So, like I've been doing a lot lately, I will go through all of the last contestants voted out of the game and list their chances of returning to a season like this. As always, I will need eight men and eight women for this to work. Also, just for fun, I will list whether or not they could have won their season if they could have avoided being the last one voted out.

The very first season brought us a contestant who was in his 70s and remains the oldest contestant to ever play Survivor. One would think this would make him a target to get voted out and that he wouldn't last that long in the game. Well, the contestant named Rudy make it incredibly far and even made the final three. When he accidently took his hand off the idol of the final immunity challenge, he cost himself his spot in the game and got voted out. He might have won against Kelly or he might have made Kelly win. We just know that Richard Hatch wouldn't have won. Would he play again? No. Probably not. He's too old to play again and I don't think he'd even want to. I hate to sound cruel, but he might die before they consider doing a season like this. The last voted out of the next season was Keith. He is the only member of Ogakor who made the merge and hasn't returned as well as the only one time player to play 41 days. He might return. I have no idea. He probably wouldn't have won, but he would have let Colby won. The next person who was the last one voted out was Lex. He is the first and just might be the only person to go crazy over one extra vote against him. He will probably return if he can and he might not have won if he made the finals. But he may also be too busy to return anyways. Kathy was the last voted out of the fourth season. She might have done worse if there were a better way of doing tie-breakers just like Neleh could have done worse as well. Kathy also messed up at the same final immunity that Rudy did. She might be a good returning player for a reason like that. She could have won. Jan was the last voted out of Thailand, but I don't think that she would return simply because that season is so poorly liked. I don't know if she would have won, but I'm guessing that she wouldn't have. Rob might have easily won Amazon if only he or maybe Matthew had won the final immunity challenge. But he's probably too busy with his podcast to do it. Johnny Fairplay is someone that I don't want to play again that much, but he could. He ranks up there with the unofficial quitters who asked to be voted out. But to put things in perspective, a lot of people who asked to be voted out are never shown with their request of asking people out. One person did it to defeat someone else on Redemption Island and another wanted voted out, but ultimately wasn't at first. When she was, it wasn't really her wishes anymore. So it's hard to classify people like that. I'd say it is just as likely that we'll never see him again as it is that he will return to play again. He probably would have lost in a final two, but it's unknown how much people hated Lillian, the person who would have been his opponent. Jenna Lewis was the last person voted out of All-Stars and I think that she could make a good player again. She might not have won against Rob, provided Shii-Ann wasn't messing with us at the reunion show that season and the rest of the jury wasn't either. Who knows if she could have beaten Rupert at a final two (probably not) or Amber (possibly) if that scenario were to happen.

The next person who was the last voted out was Scout. She would have probably lost against Chris in a final two. She might return, although I don't know since she wasn't that good in challenges. Ian was the next person to be the last one voted out. He was the first person voted out after a challenge and not at a tribal council. This makes him the first voted out contestant to not have his torch snuffed. Other contestants before him left the game without their torches being snuffed, but they had left under different conditions and two of them didn't have torches at all. He might have won the game, or just taken votes from Tom to prevent his landslide but not him winning. I imagine he will probably come back at some point. The last voted out of Guatemala was Rafe. He could have probably won the game, hence the reason he was voted out last. I imagine he would probably return. I mean, someone who originally played that season has to return at some point, right? I hope that somebody does eventually. Terry was the last person voted out of the next season. Some think that his failure to get in the final two is why they changed the format to final threes instead. He has been considered back, but hasn't returned yet. I have the feeling that he will at some point or another. He definitely would have won the game if he were a finalist. In fact, the last three men I mentioned could be good returning players on a one returnee per tribe season. The next person is Sundra. She is the first person to come in fourth place and be the last person voted out, after she lost an incredibly long fire making tie-breaker. She could return just like everyone else. She would not have won if she made it that far. Yau-Man was the last voted out of Fiji and I have the feeling that he would return, provided he gets time off of work. That reason alone is why he couldn't do the twentieth season. Would you give up your valuable job just to play a game? I wouldn't. I know Yau-Man would have probably won Fiji if he was in the finals. Denise was the next contestant to be the last one voted out. She caused controversy at the reunion show and wasn't that good of a player anyways. If she were in the finals, she could have helped Amanda win, but not herself. Cirie was screwed to many in her second season since they had a final two like they didn't for quite a long time. For that reason alone, she might return, even if this would be her fourth time playing the game. She probably would have won too, and that is why she was ultimately voted out last.

Matty was a great player in the next season. He was voted out last after he couldn't make fire. He probably could have won if he had been able to make fire, so I think that he could return just to prove that to himself and everyone else. Erin was the last voted out of the next season. She wasn't very well liked, but could have won since the tribe she started on made up most of the jury. I don't know if she would return or not. Brett could have easily won Samoa under different circumstances. He would probably return again. Jerri was a good player might have had a chance at winning her third season, provided Sandra got the boot instead of her. The only person she'd have to worry about beating is Parvati, since it was obvious that nobody would have voted for Russell to win. I have the feeling she would love to return and become a four time player.

Holly lasted the longest of all the members of the older tribe her season. If she was in fifth place instead of fourth, she would have created the first all male final four. But for now, she created what is currently the only all male final three in Survivor by being the last one voted out. She could have been in the finals and might have even had a shot at winning provided anyone but Fabio won the final immunity challenge. Let's face it, the alliance of three she was in wasn't supposed to turn on itself. I don't know for sure if she'd have won or if she'd come back, but she might have done both. Ashley was the last voted out of the next season. It was an underrated season in my opinion. I think that she might be obscure in a way, but she could easily return. Ozzy was that last voted out next. I think that he is the only runner-up to also be the last one voted out, but I could be wrong about that. He probably would have won this season under different circumstances like a Coach that doesn't like to betray people that want to make deals with him. Like I said in the runner-up post, he will probably return even if he might have said otherwise before. But that doesn't mean I will include him again. Christina was the last person voted out of One World, another underrated season like Africa. She probably wouldn't have won, unless Kim was voted out instead of her, which probably wouldn't have happened since I think Kim won final immunity. She could return because I liked her enough. It's a shame that she had that season long rivalry with Alicia that she didn't "win" until the final episode. (For the record, any Survivor rivalry is unofficial won when someone in that rivalry gets voted out or otherwise leaves the game.) The last voted out of the next season was Malcolm. He was so popular, the producers asked him back mere minutes after he was voted out the first time. He probably would have won, possibly depending on if Denise was a finalist as well or someone else was. He would and could easily return. The last one voted out in the most recently aired season is Eddie. He could have easily won Caramoan since he has more failed votes to eliminate someone than any other contestant. That is why he was voted out last. He probably would return.

So, I think the main problem with the main list I am going to post is that there could be too many men and not enough women returning. We shall see with this list. Rudy- no, Keith- maybe, Lex- maybe, Kathy- yes, Jan- no, Rob- no, Johnny Fairplay- maybe, Jenna Lewis- yes, Scout- yes, Ian- yes, Rafe- yes, Terry- yes, Sundra- maybe, Yau-Man- yes, Denise- no, Cirie- yes, Matty- yes, Erin- yes, Brett- yes, Jerri- yes, Holly- yes, Ashley- maybe, Ozzy- maybe, Christina- yes, Malcolm- yes, Eddie- yes. That makes eight men and eight women. The men are Ian, Rafe, Terry, Yau-Man, Matty, Brett, Malcolm, and Eddie. The women are Kathy, Jenna, Scout, Cirie, Erin, Jerri, Holly, and Christina.